Potato with butter

“A baked potato with butter.”

MembersTradeable (not for Ironmen)High alch 4 gp

Sources from the OSRS Wiki's drop, shop and recipe data (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0), checked 2026-10-09; the verdict and ordering are ours, built from that data. Item sprite © Jagex.

Ironman verdict

Potato with butter is a members item. Other players trade it, but an Ironman cannot use the Grand Exchange or trade, so you get your own. We list 2 recipes for it.

You can make it yourself with 39 Cooking from Baked potato and Pat of butter. Each one made gives 40 Cooking XP. That is the lowest-level of its 2 recipes.

Materials you can buy or make: Baked potato, made with 7 Cooking; Pat of butter, sold at Culinaromancer's Chest for 5 coins.

It is a material in 5 recipes, for example Chilli potato (41 Cooking), Potato with cheese (47 Cooking) and Egg potato (51 Cooking). High Alchemy (55 Magic) turns one into 4 coins. Each cast uses a nature rune, 180 coins from a rune shop, and five fire runes that a fire staff replaces, so an alch loses about 176 coins; only alch it to clear space.

Where to get it, easiest first

1.Make fromBaked potato and Pat of butter · needs 39 Cooking
2.Make fromBaked potato and Pat of not garlic butter · needs 39 Cooking

Our order: buying first, then making it (lowest skill level first), then killing for it (lowest-level monster first), then other sources. Up to three of each; the full lists are below.